A registered sexual offender is being held in the Lorain County Jail, on charges that he exposed himself to two teenage girls on Monday.
Matthew Trakas, 41, is facing two counts of public indecency. Trakas was arrested after the girls told investigators the registered sexual predator was completely naked in his doorway while putting up Halloween decorations. Trakas lives across the street from St. Mary’s Catholic School and was in full view of the school.
Trakas’ home on Fourth Street in Elyria is decorated for Halloween, but for parents and children living in the surrounding neighborhood, the most frightening thing about the house is what they are learning about the man who put up the decorations.
A neighbor who asked that she not be identified, tells Fox 8 News, “he is very kid friendly and that is weird for a single guy all by himself, I guess when you start breaking it down, it starts to look a little odd.”
Investigators concede he never should have been allowed in the neighborhood.
It seems that nearly all of his neighbors were unaware that Trakas was a registered sexual offender as the result of a 1993 assault on a four-year-old girl.
That is the same age as the daughter of one of Trakas’ current neighbors, a little girl he tried to befriend.
The child’s mother, who also did not want to be identified, says “I’m extremely scared. Somebody that nice and that polite, that you would never think that about, could actually be the one you should be scared of. You know you’re talking to him every day and you probably shouldn’t have.”
“I liken it to putting an alcoholic in a bar,” says Elyria Police Lt. Andy Eichenlaub, “it’s very difficult but they put themselves in those positions.”
According to court documents obtained by Fox 8 News, Trakas asked an appeals court in 2002 to remove his sexual predator label. But based on his prior crimes, the court turned down that request.
Sgt. Diana Nicholl runs the sexual offender registration program for the Lorain County Sheriff’s Department, and says Trakas has been reporting on his status since he got out of prison in 2008.
Sgt. Nicholl says Trakas was able to keep his background a secret from his neighbors, and got away with living so close to a school because of what amounts to a jurisdictional snafu.
“We advised the offender that he’s not allowed to live there”, said Nicholl, “however it’s a civil matter, it’s not a criminal matter and we can’t make him move.”
Nicholl says a notification was sent to Elyria Police that Trakas was violating the sexual predator law by living so close to the school, but the department did not take any action until the two girls reported on Monday that he was exposing himself.
Trakas’ neighbor says, “I think it’s crazy that nobody knew or they didn’t tell anybody, I mean I guess we could have tried to look it up online or something but like I said you wouldn’t have thought to look him up or even try to figure out who he was.”
Trakas is currently being held in the Lorain County Jail on a $125,000 bond.

